Dialogism in Contemporary Slovenian Poetry: Persona Poems and Persona Collections as an Aspect of External Dialogism

Authors

  • Varja Balžalorsky Antić

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3986/pkn.v43.i2.06

Keywords:

Slovenian poetry, Bakhtin, Mikhail, lyrical subject, persona, dialogism, Svetina, Ivo, Kramberger, Taja, Dekleva, Milan, Gorečan, Katja, Dovjak, Krištof

Abstract

This article presents an introduction into a broader project that deals with the articulation and configuration of subjects in contemporary Slovenian poetry. In the theoretical part, I provide a brief outline of the different aspects and forms of dialogism defined by Mikhail Bakhtin and propose some conclusions reached after my re-reading of Bakhtin’s thoughts on the monologic nature of poetry. In the empirical section, I situate the chronological landmarks of the increased use of dialogism in recent Slovenian poetry and list the key authors involved. An introductory difference is made between the dialogic strategies that concern the structuration of the poetic discourse and its subjects on different levels of discourse (the speaking positions and the position of the enunciative subject) on the one hand, and representations of the decomposition of the “hard” conceptions of the (philosophical) category of the subject and/or the (sociological) category of the individual by using monological procedures in the structuration of the poem on the other. From the standpoint of poetic strategies, recent phenomena of dialogism on the level of the poem are often incorporated into the apparent monologic model of the subject configuration: the plurality of the poetic subject is introduced foremost in the macro-system of the book and less in the micro-system of the poem or even the utterance. The remainder of the paper presents one of the two aspects of external dialogism that, according to Bakhtin’s typology, would be considered the external type of the two-voiced word: the introduction of the persona poem. In the end, a short analysis of five poetry collections is provided (Ivo Svetina’s The Cloud and the Mountain, Taja Kramberger’s Opus quinque dierum, Milan Dekleva’s The Exorcists of Sense, Katja Gorečan’s The Sorrows of Young Hana, and Krištof Dovjak’s Hemingway’s Lips).

References

VIRI

Čučnik, Primož. <em>Piš čez sen</em>. Ljubljana: LUD Literatura, 2019.

Dekleva, Milan. <em>Izganjalci smisla</em>. Ljubljana: LUD Literatura, 2012.

Dovjak, Krištof. <em>Hemingwayeve ustnice</em>. Ljubljana: KUD Apokalipsa, 2019.

Gorečan, Katja. <em>Trpljenje mlade Hane</em>. Ljubljana: Center za slovensko književnost, 2012.

Kramberger, Taja. <em>Opus quinque dierum</em>. Ljubljana: Center za slovensko književnost, 2009.

Osojnik, Iztok. <em>Gospod Danes</em>. Ljubljana: LUD Literatura, 2004.

Pepelnik, Ana. <em>Pod vtisom</em>. Ljubljana: LUD Šerpa, 2015.

Svetina, Ivo. <em>Oblak in gora</em>. Ljubljana: Študentska založba, 2003.

LITERATURA

Bahtin, Mihail. <em>Estetika in humanistične vede</em>. Prev. Helena Biffio et al. Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis, 1999.

Bahtin, Mihail. <em>Problemi poetike Dostojevskega</em>. Prev. Urša Zabukovec. Ljubljana: LUD Literatura, 2007.

Bahtin/Vološinov. »Discours dans la vie et discours dans la poésie« <em>Mikhaïl Bakhtine le principe dialogique suivi d’Écrits du Cercle</em>. Ur. Tzvetan Todorov. Pariz: Seuil, 1982. 181–215.

Balžalorsky Antić, Varja. »Bahtin in Ducrot v perspektivi rekonceptualizacije lirskega subjekta«. <em>Slavistična revija</em> 64.2 (2016): 165–179.

Balžalorsky Antić, Varja. <em>Lirski subjekt: rekonceptualizacija</em>. Ljubljana: Založba ZRC SAZU, 2019.

Benveniste, Émile. <em>Problemi splošne lingvistike I</em>. Prev. Igor Žagar in Bernard Nežmah. Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis, 1988.

Čučnik, Primož. »Problemi tehnopoetike«. <em>Literatura</em> 190.19 (2007): 99–108.

Ducrot, Oswald. <em>Izrekanje in izrečeno</em>. Prev. Jelica Šumič-Riha. Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis, 1988.

Deleuze, Gilles in Felix Guattari. <em>Kaj je filozofija?</em> Prev. Stojan Pelko. Ljubljana: Študentska založba, 1999.

Habjan, Jernej. <em>Janus, Prokrust, Bahtin: kvadratura Bahtinovega kroga</em>. Ljubljana: LUD Literatura, 2008.

Hühn, Peter. »Plotting the Lyric«. <em>Theory into Poetry</em>. Ur. Eva Müller-Zettelmann in Margarete Rubik. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 2005. 147–172.

Hurley, Michael D. in Michael O’Neil. <em>Poetic Form: An introduction</em>. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012.

Javornik, Miha. »Nesklenjenost Bahtinove misli kot njena odlika (Kaj je sploh dialog?)«. <em>Estetika in humanistične vede</em>. Mihail Bahtin (avtor). Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis, 1999. 383–398.

Jovanovski, Alenka. »Kako govorijo živi: esej o poeziji Miklavža Komelja«. <em>Literatura</em> 197/198.19 (2007): 175–210.

Jovanovski, Alenka. »Transformativna moč v sodobni slovenski poeziji 2004–2010: fragmenti«. <em>Sodobna slovenska književnost (1980–2010). Obdobja 29</em>. Ur. Alojzija Zupan Sosič. Ljubljana: Filozofska fakulteta, 2010. 123–129.

Jovanovski, Alenka, »Tukaj in zdaj: reinvencija sodobne ženske poezije«. <em>Šestnajst slovenskih pesnic: antologija = Szesnaście poetek słoweńskich: antologia</em>. Ur. Tatjana Jamnik, Michal Kopczyk in Agnieszka Będkowska-Kopczyk. Ljubljana: DSP, 2011. 363–378.

Juvan, Marko. »Parodija in Bahtin«. <em>Primerjalna književnost</em> 19.2 (1996): 1–28.

Juvan, Marko. <em>Intertekstualnost</em>. Ljubljana: DZS, 2000.

Juvan, Marko. <em>Literarna veda v rekonstrukciji</em>. Ljubljana: LUD Literatura, 2006.

Meschonnic, Henri. <em>Le Signe et le poème</em>. Pariz: Gallimard, 1975.

Meschonnic, Henri. <em>Critique du rythme: anthropologie historique du langage</em>. Lagrasse: Verdier, 1982.

Meschonnic, Henri. <em>Politique du rythme: politique du sujet</em>. Lagrasse: Verdier, 1995.

Pavlič, Darja. »Lirika z vidika univerzalnosti pripovedi«. <em>Primerjalna književnosti</em> 37.3 (2014): 227−238.

Müller-Zettelmann, Eva in Margarete Rubik, ur. <em>Theory Into Poetry</em>. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 2005.

Skaza, Aleksander. »Estetski humanizem Mihaila Bahtina«. <em>Estetika in humanistične vede</em>. Mihail Bahtin (avtor). Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis, 1999. 355–382.

Škulj, Jola. »Dialogizem kot nefinalizirani koncept resnice: literatura 20. stoletja in njena logika inkonkluzivnosti«. <em>Primerjalna književnost</em> 19.2 (1996): 37–48.

Wolf, Werner. »Aesthetic Illusion in Lyric Poetry?« <em>Poetica</em> 30.3/4 (1998): 251–89.

Zabukovec, Urša. »Bahtinov Dostojevski«. <em>Problemi poetike Dostojevskega</em>. Mihail Bahtin (avtor). Prev. Urša Zabukovec. Ljubljana: LUD Literatura, 2007. 309–331.

Verč, Ivan. »Izjava kot vprašanje kulturne evolucije«. <em>Primerjalna književnost</em> 19.2 (1996): 29–36.

Published

2020-09-09

Issue

Section

Thematic section