Identity of Nonidentity in Science Fiction

Authors

  • Ana Jarc

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3986/pkn.v45.i3.05

Keywords:

literature and philosophy, ecocriticism, science fiction, attitude towards animals, Adorno, Theodor W., anthropocentrism, (non)identity

Abstract

This article looks at ecological cues found in science fiction and analyses them based on the theory of the identity of nonidentity by philosopher Theodor W. Adorno. The introduction presents a type of science fiction reading that analyses the presentations of nature based on humans’ distance from nonidentity. The term nature in science fiction consists of nonhuman animals, aliens, robots, people and physical nature—in man’s relationship with these it is possible to look at the process of othering that is responsible for the cause of environmental crisis; the aforementioned groups can therefore serve for an organized analysis of the representation of the nonhuman in science fiction. The science and technology in science fiction make this genre suitable for a clear distinction between identity and nonidentity while also determining their main characteristics. In this time of ecological crisis, the discourse about anthropocentrism is an important topic. Therefore, the literary studies are also called to take part in cultivating a critical, non-anthropocentric view on literature and its representations of nature.

References

Adorno, Theodor W. <em>Minima moralia</em>. Prev. Seta Knop. Ljubljana: *cf., 2007.

Adorno, Theodor W., in Max Horkheimer. »Človek in žival«. <em>Dialektika razsvetljenstva: filozofski fragmenti</em>. Prev. Mojca Kranjc. Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis, 2006. 273–282.

Atwood, Margaret. <em>Zadnji človek</em>. Prev. Alenka Moder Saje. Tržič: Učila International, 2005.

Bajt, Drago. <em>Ljudje, zvezde, svetovi, vesolja: eseji o znanstveni fantastiki</em>. Ljubljana: Mladinska knjiga, 1982.

Berger, John. <em>Why Look at Animals?</em> London: Penguin Books, 2009.

Bradbury, Ray. »… in mesec tkal bo svojo moč«. <em>Marsovske kronike</em>. Prev. Alojz Kodre. Ljubljana: Tehniška založba Slovenije, 1980. 63–89.

Cook, Deborah. <em>Adorno on Nature</em>. New York, NY: Routledge, 2011.

Dick, Philip K. »Trgovina s pasjo hrano«. Prev. Žiga Leskovšek, Samo Resnik in Mitja Zupančič. <em>FANTAZIJA: antologija znanstvene fantastike</em>. Ur. Žiga Leskovšek in Samo Resnik. Ljubljana: Časopis za kritiko znanosti, 1990. 112–121.

Dolar, Mladen. »Strel sredi koncerta«. <em>Strel sredi koncerta</em>. Ur. Peter Klepec. Ljubljana: Cankarjeva založba, 2012. 151–202.

Duncombe, Stephen. »Odprta utopija«. Prev. Jedrt Maležič. <em>Utopija</em>. Avtor Thomas Moore. Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis, 2014. 139–191.

Feigel, Damir. <em>Pasja dlaka!</em> Gorica: Goriška matica, 1926.

Fromm, Harold. »From Transcendence to Obsolence«. <em>The Ecocriticism Reader</em>. Ur. Cheryll Glotfelty in Harold Fromm. Athens, GA; London: University of Georgia Press, 1996. 30–39.

Gradišnik, Branko. »Raziskovalec«. <em>Mavrična krila</em>. Ur. Drago Bajt. Ljubljana: Tehniška založba Slovenije, 1978. 269–273.

Haraway, Donna J. <em>Opice, kiborgi in ženske</em>. Prev. Valerija Vendramin in Tina Potrato. Ljubljana: ŠOU, 1999.

Jarc, Ana. <em>Ekokritika v znanstveni fantastiki</em>. Magistrsko delo. Ljubljana, 2021.

Jay, Martin. <em>Adorno</em>. Prev. Simon Krek, Slavko Gaber in Janez Krek. Ljubljana: Krtina, 1991.

Jia, Xia. »Night Journey of the Dragon-Horse«. <em>Invisible Planets</em>. Ur. in prev. Ken Liu. London: Head of Zeus Ltd., 2016. 133–149.

Kordigel, Metka. <em>Znanstvena fantastika</em>. Ljubljana: DZS, 1994.

Lem, Stanisław. <em>Solaris</em>. Prev. Tatjana Jamnik. Ljubljana: Družba Piano, 2010.

Lombardo, Tom. »Science Fiction: The Evolutionary Mythology of the Future«. <em>Journal of Futures Studies</em> 20.2 (2015): 5–24.

Losada, José Manuel. »Introduction. Myth and Science Fiction: A Complex Coexistence«. <em>Myth and Science Fiction: A Complex Coexistence</em>. Ur. José Manuel Losada in Antonella Lipscomb. Madrid: Sial Pigmalión, 2021. 15–19.

Manes, Christopher. »Nature and Silence«. <em>The Ecocriticism Reader</em>. Ur. Cheryll Glotfelty in Harold Fromm. Athens, GA; London: University of Georgia Press, 1996. 15–29.

Quifan, Chen. »The Year of the Rat«. <em>Invisible Planets</em>. Ur. in prev. Ken Liu. London: Head of Zeus Ltd., 2016. 21–49.

Pečjak, Vid. »Odisej se vrača«. <em>Kam je izginila Ema Lauš</em>. Ljubljana: Mladinska knjiga, 1980. 13–53.

Pečjak, Vid. »Sonce«. <em>Kam je izginila Ema Lauš</em>. Ljubljana: Mladinska knjiga, 1980. 157–162.

Remec, Miha. »Ikar in želva«. <em>Astralni svetilniki</em>. Ljubljana: KIKI KERAM, 1993. 169–178.

Richter, Gerhard, in Theodor W. Adorno. »Who’s Afraid of the Ivory Tower? A Conversation with Theodor W. Adorno«. <em>Monatshefte</em> 94.1 (2002): 10–23.

Russ, Joanna. »Ko se spremeni«. Prev. Žiga Leskovšek, Samo Resnik in Mitja Zupančič. <em>FANTAZIJA: antologija znanstvene fantastike</em>. Ur. Žiga Leskovšek in Samo Resnik. Ljubljana: Časopis za kritiko znanosti, 1990. 36–42.

Shelley, Mary. <em>Frankenstein</em>. Prev. Boris Verbič. Ljubljana: DZS, 1995.

Shippey, Tom. »Literarni vratarji in fabrilna tradicija«. <em>Znanstvena fantastika, kanonizacija, marginalizacija in akademsko</em>. Ur. Gary Westfahl in George Slusser. Prev. Pika Kofol. Ljubljana: Založniški atelje Blodnjak, 2004. 14–39.

VanderMeer, Jeef. <em>Annihilation</em>. London: 4th Estate, 2015.

Vercors. <em>Sprijene živali</em>. Prev. Lojze Uršič. Ljubljana: Prešernova družba, 1969.

Virk, Tomo. »Mislec neidentitete«. <em>Beležke o literaturi</em>. Avtor Theodor Adorno. Ljubljana: Cankarjeva založba, 1999. 337–354.

Wells, H. G. <em>Vojna svetov</em>. Prev. Bogdan Gradišnik. Ljubljana: Tehniška založba Slovenije, 1990.

Published

2022-11-07

Issue

Section

Articles